Which sentence does NOT use critical correctly?

A. I’m going to sing now. Please don’t be too critical because this is my first time singing in public.
B. All the judges on talent shows are supposed to be critical, but some judges feel for the performers and always give high scores.
C. Every good writer knows how to edit with a critical eye.
D. He was very critical about my story. He happily read it and told me how great it was.